Guides for av fleet operations managers
Vehicle out of service: the reason codes an AV fleet depot should use
A car held back from riders needs more than a red flag on the board. Nine reason codes, the line between a hard hold and a policy hold, a second field for what the car is waiting on, and how to mark, clear and count the cars that are held.
By XoomPark Editorial Team ·
| Code | The car is out because | Type | Cleared by | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAF | A defect likely to affect safe operation was found or reported | Hard | Repair, then a signed certification | 49 CFR 396.11;3 396.71 |
| RCL | The VIN shows an unrepaired safety recall | Hard | The recall remedy, then a clean lookup | NHTSA8 |
| BRK | It cannot move, or cannot finish its trip | Hard | Repair and a test | The transit database's major mechanical failure6 |
| DMG | Collision or body damage | Hard until inspected | Repair, or a documented release | Depot policy (our assumption) |
| POL | It can drive, but depot policy keeps it back | Policy | Repair, or a supervisor's release | The transit database's other mechanical failures6 |
| PM | Scheduled maintenance is due | Planned | Work order closed | 49 CFR 396.34 |
| CLN | Contamination beyond the turnaround clean | Policy | Cleaning sign-off | Depot exposure plan (our assumption) |
| ADM | Registration, insurance or a permit has lapsed | Hard | Document on file | Depot policy (our assumption) |
| MKR | The vehicle's maker or its trained staff pulled the car | Hard | The maker's release | Maker's procedure (our assumption) |
What does out of service mean for an AV fleet car?
Two cautions before you borrow from them. The criteria are updated annually, effective April 1 of each year, so a copy pinned to the wall goes stale.5 And these rules were written for commercial motor vehicles; the inspection report rule, for one, does not apply to a private nonbusiness carrier of passengers, a driveaway-towaway operation or a carrier operating only one commercial motor vehicle.3 Whether they bind your cars is a question for your compliance lead. They are still the best public model of what a hold should mean.
A depot's own status is wider than the roadside one. It also covers cars that could drive but that you choose to keep back. It does not cover a car that is charging or in its turnaround clean: those are statuses on the way to ready, and counting them as out of service hides the cars that are really stuck.
Hard holds and policy holds: the split the National Transit Database uses
That line is worth copying. A hard hold is one nobody can talk their way past: a safety defect, an open recall, a car that will not move. A policy hold is a choice the depot made: a warning light you do not release with, a broken interior part, a scuffed panel. Our rule, an assumption and not a published standard: a hard hold is cleared only by the fix and its sign-off, while a policy hold can also be released by a named supervisor with a note on the record.
Report the two apart. Hours lost to hard holds are the price of safety. Hours lost to policy holds are a price you set yourself, and the only number on the board you can change by changing a rule.
Why a reason code and a waiting-on field are two different things
- Waiting-on values we suggest: diagnosis, parts, a technician, a vendor or dealer, a bay, sign-off.
- The reason code is set once, when the car comes out, and changes only if the diagnosis proves it wrong.
- The waiting-on value changes as often as it needs to, and each change is time-stamped.
- A third field holds the part or system, so "SAF, brakes, waiting on parts" reads as one line.
The trucking industry's coding standard works the same way. The American Trucking Associations' Technology & Maintenance Council says its Vehicle Maintenance Reporting Standards, developed in 1970, provide a single, concise coding convention, and the council is their official custodian.7 The standard keeps a separate code key for each question: Code Key 15, Work Accomplished, is a two-digit code for what the technician did, such as 02 Clean, 27 Align and 33 Tighten, and Code Key 18, Technician Failure Code, has over 90 codes for why a part failed, such as 10 Bent, 44 Worn and 60 Noisy.7 One field, one question. The council also says the level of coding used is entirely up to the user,7 which is why nine codes can be enough to start.
How do you mark a car out of service and bring it back?
- Who can place a hold: anyone who finds the condition. Who can clear it: only the role in the table above.
- Moving a held car: the federal rule counts towing as operating, with one exception, that a marked vehicle may be towed away by a vehicle using a crane or hoist.2 Write your own yard-move rule for each hard code and print it on the tag.
- A fault found on the road: a vehicle discovered to be unsafe may continue only to the nearest place where repairs can safely be made, and only if that is less hazardous to the public than leaving it on the highway.1
- Coming back: before the vehicle is operated again, the carrier certifies that the defect has been repaired or that repair is unnecessary.3 Record who signed and when; that time is the car's time out.
- After a roadside inspection: the carrier certifies within 15 days that all violations noted have been corrected, and keeps a copy for 12 months.2
Keep the history. The federal maintenance rule requires a record of inspection, repairs and maintenance showing their date and nature, plus a means to indicate the nature and due date of the work to come, kept for 1 year where the vehicle is housed or maintained and for 6 months after it leaves the carrier's control.4 Inspection reports and their repair certifications are kept three months.3 We suggest keeping the hold record with them, whichever rule applies to you.
How do you count out-of-service cars?
An example, with made-up numbers to show the arithmetic. A 60-car roster has 1,440 car-hours in a day. Two cars sit on safety holds all day (48 car-hours), one on a recall hold all day (24), three take 6 hours each for planned maintenance (18) and two sit 12 hours each on policy holds (24). That is 114 car-hours out of 1,440, an out-of-service rate of 7.9 percent. The policy holds are 24 of the 114, or 21 percent: the share you could win back without touching a wrench.
A car waiting on a charger is not in this count; it is a charging status. When stalls are what keep cars in the yard, XoomPark arranges AV fleet charging at existing stations in hours their stalls sit unused, never blocks a station's regular customers and never pushes a station past its monthly peak.
When reason codes are the wrong tool
- An enforcement officer placed the vehicle out of service. The notice controls: the vehicle is not operated until every repair it requires is complete,2 whatever your own code says.
- You need to know which part failed and how. That is part and failure coding, such as the Vehicle Maintenance Reporting Standards,7 sitting under the reason code, not replacing it.
- The question is whether the driving system is fit to drive. That call belongs to the vehicle's maker and its trained staff; the MKR code only records that they made it.
- You run a handful of cars. Our assumption: below about ten, a written list with a name beside each car does the same job.
Questions AV fleet operations managers ask
What does out of service mean for a vehicle?
What happens when a vehicle is placed out of service at a roadside inspection?
Can a car be driven while it is out of service?
How many reason codes should a depot use?
Is a car waiting on a charger out of service?
How do you know a recall hold is cleared?
Sources
- U.S. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 49 CFR 396.7, Unsafe operations forbidden (eCFR)
- U.S. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 49 CFR 396.9, Inspection of motor vehicles and intermodal equipment in operation (eCFR)
- U.S. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 49 CFR 396.11, Driver vehicle inspection report(s) (eCFR)
- U.S. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, 49 CFR 396.3, Inspection, repair, and maintenance (eCFR)
- Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance: North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria
- Federal Transit Administration: National Transit Database (NTD) Glossary
- American Trucking Associations, Technology & Maintenance Council: Vehicle Maintenance Reporting Standards (VMRS) Overview
- NHTSA: Check for Recalls (VIN and license plate lookup)
Sources are public. XoomPark isn't affiliated with the companies referenced in this post.
Authorship
Written by XoomPark Editorial Team in collaboration with Claude Fable 5.2
Role breakdown: Topic selection and publishing by XoomPark Editorial Team; research, source checks against primary sources and draft prose by Claude Fable 5.2.